By Paul Lang, Editor, Sell It!
May 10th, 2000
| Product: | FindWhat.com |
| Description: | Search engine with paid-for rankings |
| Available: | Now |
| Pricing: | Keywords bid on by advertisers |
When GoTo.com was launched back in June ’98 it radically altered the search engine landscape. Prior to its launch, search engines fell broadly in to two categories, the true search engines (such as Alta Vista) and human-reviewed directories (such as Yahoo!).
Getting a good listing in any of these ‘traditional’ search engines or directories can prove to be very difficult. A whole new science (or black art as some would claim!) called Search Engine Optimization (SEO) has evolved to provide varying (and even contradictory) recipes for getting good listings on the search engines, whilst volumes have been written on the seemingly impossible process of getting listed on Yahoo!.
GoTo.com changed all this. Overnight, getting listed on a search engine became automatic, with the ranking determined solely by how much an advertiser was willing to pay. (See our review of GoTo.com for full details of how this works) .
I’ve always been a big fan of GoTo.com and I still spend the lion’s share of my advertising budget with them. However, GoTo.com is starting to become a victim of its own success. As it has become more popular, the bid amount needed to secure a good ranking has steadily increased and unless you are willing and able to continually revise your bids upwards, the traffic that GoTo.com delivers will tail off. To illustrate this, I experienced a 30% drop in traffic between February and April despite increasing some of my bids during this period.
According to GoTo.com, the average keyword price has risen from $0.08 to $0.19 over the last 12 months and this trend looks likely to continue. However, the bids for popular keywords have risen even more dramatically. For example, my most important keyword is ‘e-commerce’: when I first started advertising on GoTo.com I could easily have got a top-10 position with a bid of $1 – now I would need to bid over $5!
Not surprisingly, the success of GoTo.com has inspired a number of competitors to spring up and Nathan Power lists no fewer than 25 on his new Web site PayPerClickSearchEngines.com.
Of these competitors, FindWhat.com is the biggest, claiming 2 million searches per day against GoTo.com’s 5 million. And it’s growing rapidly too – back in January they ran less than 0.5 million searches per day.
Currently, the bid prices for top rankings on FindWhat.com are generally much lower than on GoTo.com. For example, the table below compares current bid prices needed to achieve top, tenth, and twentieth ranking for the keyword ‘e-commerce’:
| Ranking | GoTo.com | FindWhat.com |
| #1 | $6.02 | $0.94 |
| #10 | $5.29 | $0.55 |
| #20 | $2.52 | $0.26 |
Opening a FindWhat.com advertising account is a straightforward process and only requires a $25 (non-refundable) deposit. If you’re already a GoTo.com advertiser you’ll be pleased to learn that FindWhat.com has imitated most of GoTo.com’s management features, although in general I find the FindWhat.com interface easier to use. However, there are several key differences between the two search engines that are worth pointing out:
- GoTo.com review keyword purchases for relevancy before adding them to their database, while FindWhat.com adds them immediately. Whilst having your bids listed immediately might seem attractive, there is a danger that unscrupulous advertisers could bid on irrelevant keywords and thus lower the relevance of search results. Although FindWhat.com have a similar relevancy rules to GoTo.com’s I can’t help feeling that it must be much more difficult to enforce these after the bids have been accepted and added to the system.
- Although FindWhat.com’s reporting system presents good summary information in a format that is clearer than GoTo.com, it lacks the flexibility and depth of GoTo.com’s system. For example, FindWhat.com’s reports cannot easily be downloaded to a PC for further analysis.
- FindWhat.com also lacks GoTo.com’s advanced payment features. For example, I have set up GoTo.com to automatically add more money to my account once it falls to a certain level – no similar feature exists on FindWhat.com.
Verdict: Although FindWhat.com’s bid prices will no doubt eventually rise to match GoTo.com’s, currently it looks like a good, low cost way of driving targeted traffic to your Web site.
Related Posts:
- GoTo.com – Product Review - By Paul Lang, Editor, Sell It! April 3rd, 1999 Product GoTo.com Description Search engine with paid-for rankings Available Now Pricing Keywords bid on by advertisers...
- ClickTrade Affiliate Network – Product Review - By Paul Lang, Editor, Sell It! June 6th, 1998 The ClickTrade link partner program has been around for some time now, seemingly locked in an...
- Nothing But Net – Product Review - By Paul Lang, Editor, Sell It! November 3rd, 1999 Product: Nothing But ‘Net: How I Generated $750,000 in Internet Revenues with Virtually No Advertising Costs...
- Fraud Prevention Tools – Product Review - By Paul Lang, Editor, Sell It! February 28th, 2001 Two weeks ago I described some manual checks that you can use to help prevent fraud...
- Alternative Payment Solutions – Product Review - By Paul Lang, Editor, Sell It! May 23rd, 2001 If you’re a seasoned Internet shopper like I am, you are probably quite happy to use...